Video review: BMW M5 v Mercedes-AMG E63 S

Video review: BMW M5 v Mercedes-AMG E63 S
Video review: BMW M5 v Mercedes-AMG E63 S

Head-to-head on the roads in what could be the best two megasports saloons you can buy

What are the ideal ingredients for a brilliant 2018 sports saloon? A thundering twin-turbocharged V8 making pots of power? Four-wheel drive, but with the option of switching off the fronts for a little extra fun? Enough doors, interior space and luxury to allow you to share a stonking experience with three others?

That’s what both BMW and Mercedes-Benz reckon makes a super saloon, sports sedan or whatever else you care to call it, because both the M5 and the E63 S deliver exactly that package.


The 4-litre twin-turbo V8 Mercedes has 603bhp and 627lb ft of torque. It weighs 45kg short of two tonnes, does the 0-62mph run in 3.5 seconds and goes on to 186mph.

The 4.4-litre twin-turbo V8 BMW has 591bhp and 553lb ft of torque, but weighs 100kg less than the Merc so is even quicker – slightly – through the 0-62 at 3.4sec. Its top speed is limited to 155mph.

After a sound thrashing on British roads, our two video testers Matt and Dan struggle to separate these German masterpieces. To find out which one they eventually (and narrowly) picked, go here

Now it’s your turn to decide between these two cars. The good news is that it’s a no-lose situation. They’re both amazing.

Read more: 

Review: BMW M5

Review: Mercedes-AMG E63 S

History of the BMW M5

Jaguar F-Type - thunder in the glens

A polite notice to anyone planning a trip to Scotland – don’t bother. It’s deadly dull, the scenery is awful and the roads

Skoda Octavia vRS 245 review - it's sensible, silly

Every brand within the VW Group has a carefully curated identity. Audi is the premium brand, Seat is the youthful stylish one, VW is the bastion

Ford Kuga ST-Line X review

Sales of new diesel cars are falling, with negative press, scandals such as Dieselgate and legislation targeting oil-burning engines all contributing

Nissan X-Trail review: trail-blazer left playing catch-up

Nissan’s X-Trail has been with us in its current guise for a couple of years now.Radically different from the original model it took